Have a question about how the TVTropes wiki works? No one knows this community better than the people in it, so ask away! Ask the Tropers is the page you come to when you have a question burning in your brain and the support pages didn't help.
It's not for everything, though. For a list of all the resources for your questions, click here. You can also go to this Directory thread
for ongoing cleanup projects.
Ask the Tropers is for:
- • General questions about the wiki, how it works, and how to do things.
- • Reports of problems with wiki articles, or requests for help with wiki articles.
- • Reports of misbehavior or abuse by other tropers.
Ask the Tropers is not for:
- • Help identifying a trope. See TropeFinder.
- • Help identifying a work. See MediaFinder.
- • Asking if a trope example is valid. See the Trope Talk forum.
- • Proposing new tropes. See TropeLaunchPad.
- • Making bug reports. See QueryBugs.
- • Asking for new wiki features. See QueryWishlist.
- • Chatting with other tropers. See our forums.
- • Reporting problems with advertisements. See this forum topic.
- • Reporting issues on the forums. Send a Holler instead.
Ask the Tropers:
openAdding "the one where" lines to Star Trek: TNG recaps. Live Action TV
I've always enjoyed the "the one where/with" lines at the beginning of pages for Rocky, James Bond and Star Trek films, as well as Doctor Who episode recaps. I'd like to add some examples to TNG recaps, can I just dive right in and do it? Or do I need to get clearance from mods, or request permission in a Trope Workshop first?
Thanks.
Edited by 773202lunaopenWhen flaws are appealing to someone Live Action TV
While friends are listing someone's flaws to show her that he's completely wrong for her, she actually finds those flaws appealing, making him more attractive.
openDead Boy Detectives Index Question Live Action TV
Dead Boy Detectives 2024 is listed on the Teen Drama Index. While the show is about teens, teens are not the target audience. It's rather disconcerting to see a show with a fairly unflinching gore factor listed between Dawson's Creek and Degrassi. I threw up a question on this listing on the discussion page, but have gotten no response there, so throwing the question out here. Does it belong there? Yea or Nay?
openHeavy-handed "badge of honor" troping Live Action TV
rr3elite appears to have a major Single-Issue Wonk focused on showing off the villainy of the character Zein from Kamen Rider Outsiders and their appearances in other Kamen Rider media, including this week's episode of Kamen Rider Gotchard. I initially reported them on ATT before for shoehorning in Fan Myopia-laden comparisons to other works through misuse of various tropes, but it is now clear that was a symptom of a much bigger wonk, mostly afflicting Zein's sheet, the page for Outsiders itself, and various pages for Gotchard (YMMV, antagonists sheet, Nightmare Fuel, #33's recap) where Zein's appearance is concerned.
I haven't sent any notifiers because there's too many offending edits to comb through, but a lot of their edits consist of what they have previously been reported for, plus Bold Inflation, countless sentence structure and grammar errors, and "look at how horrible this person is" examples that stretch Zein's villainynote it is a sapient AI that has placed the world into an authoritarian surveillance state with the intent of mass genocide and has manipulated the heroes into giving it its resources, but I would hesitate to call a lot of its actions deliberately symbolic or nuanced beyond face value.. They also added Speculative Troping examples to Gotchard #33's recap suggesting Zein would have had a darker and more dramatic role in the episode, when in reality he only appears to kill one of the unambiguously-evil villains in the episode and leaves just as quickly to promote Outsiders.
I'm not sure if this is a policy violation in its own right, but I cannot deny in good faith that it is starting to compromise their writing and thus the quality of the pages they are editing.
Edited by TrocyteVopenEdit War Live Action TV
- On the YMMV page of Kamen Rider Gotchard
- ddyingle added a lot of Natter on various elements of the page.
- I removed all of them and sent them a notifier.
- Not only did they re-add one of them in a different place, but they added more instances despite the notifier I sent them.
openEpisode page mis-numbered Live Action TV
In the recap section and individual page for Severance (2022), both the eighth and ninth (final) episodes are titled as episode eight - how can I edit these so the final episode is titled episode nine in both sections?
resolved Spoiler warning best practise? Live Action TV
Hi all,
Given that some characters’ entries for Shōgun (2024) are very heavily blanked out with spoiler tags, does it make more sense to simply add a bold spoiler warning at the top of the page? Is that a free action when pages are looking a bit Swiss cheese-ish? (I asked in the page's Discussion thread a couple of weeks ago, but no one has replied).
Edited by lexiiopenEdit war on Fallout 2024's YMMV page Live Action TV
On April 14th, troper Phantomskyler added this entry to the Fallout TV show's YMMV page:
- And You Thought It Would Fail: Leading up to the premier there was much grumbling and speculation over the quality of the series, with diehard fans worried about it being a similarly lackluster and divisive adaptation like Halo's tv series, and a rather loud minority of culture war youtubers claiming it will be a "woke failure" criticizing it's female and black protagonists alongside supporting character Dane being nonbinary being the show "catering for diversity points and not fans." After the premier was wildly well recieved by audiences and critics alike the former were pleasantly surprised (though some had minor gripes concerning the lore aspects) and the former were forced to very quietly slink away and keep their mouths shut when their predictions (predicably) didn't match reality.
I grinded it down for being a blatant ROCEJ violation and sent him a notifier for it. Two days later, he added a reworded entry again as a subpoint without discussion, which was then edited by unrelated tropers to this:
- To a lesser extent, a loud minority of "culture war youtubers" (content creators known for exaggerated and inflammatory takes criticizing "forced diversity" in media) were quick to lambast the show leading up to the premiere due to its female and black protagonists, claiming it would bomb as bad as The Marvels (2023) or the aforementioned Halo TV series, and that it will be universally loathed by everyone, especially fans. When the show dropped and became highly praised by fans and regular viewers alike, most of this group quickly sung the series' praises, moved on to different media to criticize, or (in more extreme cases) either used the vocal backlash against the handling of the NCR and (supposedly) Vegas or simply let their personal biases justify them giving the show a negative review. That being said... a portion of that small minority didn't even watch the show, and just confirmed their biases with a couple clips (namely, Titus running away from a bear being seen as an insult to the Brotherhood and Lucy and Max's "sex talk") without the context that explain what is happening in these scenes.
On April 17th, the entry was removed by troper Incredible Fulk 1 with the edit reason: "Really? That was such a small minority."
Phantomskyler then re-added the entry wholesale on April 19th with the edit reason: "Re adding since it doesn't break editing rules & shouldn't have been removed."
resolved No Title Live Action TV
A few years ago I saw a TV show where rich kids were sent to poor places to live there for a while. The episode I remember featured a California girl sent to an Indian village. Does anyone remember the title of the show?
openUnsourced Twilight Zone claim Live Action TV
I've seen some entries claiming Rod Serling intended Henry Bemis from "Time Enough at Last" to be unsympathetic and for his fate at the end to be a karmic punishment, but I'm not aware of any source for this. I found one article quoting Serling's daughter as saying he didn't like "underachievers who thought the world owed them something" and the article attempts to tie that to the ending of that episode, but that seems to be the conjecture of the person who wrote the article. I was able to find that quote in context and she was just talking about Serling's overall values and doesn't mention the episode at all. Here's a link to it:
The script also describes the episode's antagonists (the bank president and Bemis's wife) in very unflattering terms, so that makes it seem even more unlikely that this was Serling's intent. Does anyone know of a source for this, or should those entries be cut?
Edited by Javertshark13openHow to add images to recap indexes Live Action TV
I’ve been thinking about adding recap cover art to the recap index of Charmed (1998). So do you have to take this to Image Pickin' or is it a different process than normally?
Edited by CanuckMcDuck1openHow to word this Live Action TV
Having just seen the show, I've started editing the page of Ripley (staring Andrew Scott as the titular Tom Ripley).
In it, there is an Actor Allusion as John Malkovich plays a character (and in the trailer even says he like Ripley's name, though the context is different in the show itself), having played the role of Tom Ripley in Ripley's Game (2002). This has already been added.
However, on top of this, it's revealed he plays the character of Reeves Minot, a character with a major role in the plot of Ripley's Game. Would this be playing the actor allusion trope straight further, exaggerating it, or something else?
resolved Folders Live Action TV
I've got a Funny page that's rather unwieldy. I want to give each episode its own folder, BUT each episode's heading links to its recap page. How do I do the folders while preserving the links?
resolved What exactly was Zero Context about this example Live Action TV
I made this page today and I explained everything that happened in the scene and why it was sad and more and it still got deleted.
resolved Page splitting procedure - Alex Rider (2020) Live Action TV
Hello,
Ahead of Season 3 premiering on April 3, I have been planning to split off the Alex Rider live-action series from the pages relating to the books, given that it has distinct characters and continuity, and the ill-fated 2006 movie adaptation has its own page too.
However, I just wanted to double-check the procedure for performing this hard split (if indeed it is appropriate to do this), and what to do with the original Series/AlexRider page, given the large number of inbound links — should it become a redirect? I think only the Series/, YMMV/, Awesome/ and Funny/ pages need to be moved to a new Alex Rider (2020) namespace, and wicks changed to reflect this?
I've asked in the splitting merged works thread but received no response.
Thanks, Azorius 24
Edited by Azorius24openMacgyver (2016) Recap page? Live Action TV
Hi, just wondering what happened to the Recap page for Macgyver 2016? I'm sure there was one because I remember formatting some episode titles, but it seems to have vanished. Anyone?
I think possibly no individual episode pages had been made. That's probably due to the idiosyncratic episode titles; from Season 2 onwards, most titles have + symbols in them, which I guess may have put people off if they weren't sure how to proceed. Could that have anything to do with the page disappearing?
openGhosts episode entry Live Action TV
I made mistakes with a prior entry and requested it be cut.
Is it alright to try again?
openHow do I correct an incorrect episode title? Live Action TV
I entered an episode title for a recap page, but have just learned the title has been changed. How do I correct this?
openPolitically-biased entry removal Live Action TV
On Mexicans Love Speedy Gonzales, Clear Air Turbulence recently cut out an example concerning Last Man Standing with this edit reason:
"This doesn't apply - there's no example given of a "leftist" character that is loved by "leftists", this is just an excuse for someone defending right wing propaganda to say "Leftists love it too!""
I think like they were making a revision fueled by political bias (and not hiding it at all, judging by the edit reason), as the removed entry did attempt to give examples of characters "liked" by liberals. I believe it counts as a possible ROCEJ violation. What should we do about it? Should we give them a warning for it?
Edited by DongwaChan
On the fanfiction recommendation page for Dead Boy Detectives (2024), dozens of fanfics have been added in the last two days (because that's how long the page has existed) by Shanwooo444 which have the summaries copy-and-pasted straight from Archive of Our Own. I changed the only one that I've actually read, but I can't re-summarize the rest of them because I haven't read those fanfics. I've also noticed that all those fanfics being added rapidly have a variety of different names listed as "Recommended by," but a quick glance at the history of the page shows that they were all posted by the same person. So it is definitely just the one person who is copy-and-pasting the exact summaries from Archive of Our Own.
Anyone who is a fan of the show want to swing over there and help edit the ever-growing number of fanfictions being recommended there?